To determine if population density in areas closed to fishing in Narragansett Bay is causing differences in the reproductive potential of the organisms, this study used two approaches to determine the reproductive condition of the animals. The first approach consisted in employing a gravimetric condition index (CI) to evaluate the general condition of quahogs from nine different sites, 3 sites open conditionally for fishing (conditional areas) and 6 sites closed to fishing. The second approach was a determination of gonadal index (GI) of a subset of the sample sites, by histological observation of gonadal tissue sections. Initial sampling included determination of CI only, and lasted from March 25 to Sep. 22, 2005. The subset of six of the sites was sampled the next year (2006), every three weeks from April 15 until Sep. 28 to determine CI and the gonadal index (GI). Results show that there is a significant difference between the CI of northern quahogs from conditional areas and quahogs from closed areas (P < 0.001). There is a significant difference in GI between sites at (P < 0.10). The GI in conditional areas was consistently higher than in closed sites indicating that maturation and reproductive stages are more prevalent in conditional areas than in closed sites. When sites were separated into three categories: conditional fishing sites; coves; and Providence River sites, the GI and CI of the conditional areas were always higher than the CI and GI of all the other sites. The coves had intermediate indices, and the Providence River sites always had the lowest indices. The results indicate that the populations of quahogs in the closed sites sampled are not completing the gonadal cycle as expected and that the reproductive capability of the quahogs in conditional areas is higher than those in closed areas. Possible explanations to this condition include lower water quality in the closed areas, low dissolved oxygen concentration especially during the summer, poor bottom conditions and high population density. Although, not one single characteristic of the environment is solely responsible for the reproductive condition of the quahog population, density appears to have significant effect.